Immanuel and the crisis of leadership

Immanuel and the crisis of leadership
By Rev’d Fiifi AFENYI-DONKOR

Isaiah 7:14 is one of the most familiar and beloved biblical texts during the Christmas season. It speaks of a divine sign given to King Ahaz: “Behold, a virgin shall conceive and bear a son and shall call his name Immanuel.” The name Immanuel is etymologically derived from immanu (“with us”) and El (“God”) and is thus commonly translated as “God with us.”

For Christians, the fullest reality of this text finds expression in the birth of Jesus Christ. The Gospel of Matthew explicitly employs Isaiah 7:14 as a proof text, declaring its fulfillment in the birth of Jesus Christ (Matthew 1:23). In this sense, the prophecy rightly occupies a central place in Christmas reflections.

However, when read within its historical setting, Isaiah 7:14 addresses a much deeper and more urgent concern: a crisis of leadership at the heart of nation-building. The sign is not first given to explain the mechanics of a miraculous birth, but to confront a fearful king and a destabilized nation with the reality of God’s active presence amid political uncertainty and moral failure. Immanuel, therefore, is not only a doctrine to be celebrated but a theological challenge to leadership, governance, and public responsibility.

Leadership in Crisis

The background of Isaiah 7 describes a crisis that is not merely political; it is fundamentally a crisis of leadership. King Ahaz ruled Judah during a time of intense geopolitical pressure. Threatened by the Syro-Ephraimite coalition, he faced a defining moment that required courage, trust, and moral clarity. His response, as scholar Walter Brueggemann notes, exemplifies a leadership crisis: fear-driven decisions and political expediency that undermined national stability. His failure to trust in God’s guidance offers a timeless lesson on the consequences of weak or compromised leadership.

Instead of turning to God, Ahaz panicked. He pursued questionable foreign alliances and adopted policies driven by fear rather than covenant faithfulness. Judah’s challenge was not only the armies at its borders but also the instability of a leader who lacked spiritual conviction and ethical resolve.

Isaiah confronts Ahaz with a stark warning: “If you do not stand firm in faith, you will not stand at all” (Isaiah 7:9). Ahaz refuses to trust God, masking his unbelief with a veneer of religious politeness. His leadership collapses under three interrelated failures:

• Fear-driven decision-making
• Compromise for short-term political gain
• A lack of spiritual grounding

When leaders lose their moral centre, nations lose their direction. It is against this backdrop of fear, political anxiety, and failed leadership that Isaiah introduces one of Scripture’s most enduring and theologically rich signs.

God’s Response: A Sign of True Leadership

Into this backdrop of fear and failed leadership, God gives a definitive sign: “A virgin [Hebrew: almah, often translated ‘young woman’] shall conceive and bear a son and shall call His name Immanuel” (Isaiah 7:14). Christian tradition, especially in Matthew 1:23, interprets the Greek parthenos as “virgin,” seeing in Jesus Christ the ultimate fulfillment of this prophecy.

The prophecy carries a dual fulfillment:

• Immediate context: a sign of reassurance to Judah that God had not abandoned the nation despite Ahaz’s failure.
• Messianic fulfillment: a forward-looking promise realized fully in Jesus Christ, through whom God establishes ultimate justice, peace, and abiding presence.

This Christmas season, the birth of Jesus, true Immanuel, reminds us that:

1. God bypasses failed human leadership. Divine faithfulness is not limited by the failure of those in power; God addresses the wider community beyond Ahaz.
2. God redefines leadership. The sign of a child symbolizes vulnerability, humility, and new beginnings, deliberately contrasting with Ahaz’s insecurity, power politics, and reliance on imperial might.
3. God reveals a greater Leader. Isaiah 9:6–7 describes Him as Wonderful Counsellor, Mighty God, Everlasting Father, Prince of Peace. Where Ahaz embodied fear, this coming Leader, fulfilled in Christ, embodies wisdom, justice, peace, and the sustaining presence of God.

Parallels for Contemporary Ghana

The narrative of Isaiah does not map directly onto modern Ghana, yet its theological resonance is unmistakable. We are not awaiting a theocratic ruler; rather, the call is for leaders and citizens alike to embody the character of Immanuel, justice, integrity, humility, and selfless service, within a pluralistic democratic society.

Like Judah under Ahaz, Ghana faces moments when:

• Ethical compromises threaten the common good.
• Fear shapes political and economic decisions.
• Trust in public institutions becomes fragile.
• Public confidence in leadership wavers.

Isaiah 7 reminds us that national flourishing depends not merely on policies or personalities but on leadership grounded in moral conviction. When leaders act with integrity, institutions strengthen, trust grows, and the common good is served. When leadership collapses into fear and compromise, everything else weakens with it.

Reclaiming Leadership Shaped by Immanuel

Leadership today, whether in government, business, church, or home, must reflect the character of Immanuel: justice, integrity, humility, and selfless service.

Leadership grounded in faith, not fear

Leaders should choose integrity over insecurity, prioritizing long-term national wellbeing over short-term advantage. Transparent decision-making and openness to independent scrutiny are essential.

Leadership shaped by Immanuel’s character

True leadership lifts the humble, confronts systems that exploit the poor, and reforms institutions that protect the powerful. Vulnerability, compassion, and righteousness define this approach.

Citizens empowered to act

Trust in divine leadership does not breed passivity. Citizens become agents of God’s presence through:

• Integrity in action: Honesty in professional and personal dealings, rejecting bribery and cronyism.
• Active stewardship: Mentoring young leaders, strengthening community peacebuilding, and participating in local governance.
• Prophetic advocacy: Moving beyond complaint to organized civic engagement, using Right to Information laws, oversight mechanisms, and the ballot to reward competence and integrity.

Conclusion

Isaiah 7:14 teaches that hope is not found in political manoeuvring or short-term solutions, but in God’s abiding presence. Leadership, national and personal, thrives when it is grounded in the character of Immanuel.

As we consider what it would look like if every Ghanaian leader and citizen embodied the courage, integrity, and compassion of Immanuel this season, let that reflection move us from admiration of principles to their faithful implementation in public life.

As Ghana journeys through this Christmas season, may our leaders seek wisdom, our institutions embrace integrity, and our citizens live truthfully and act justly. May this be the season we turn that admiration into faithful, courageous action in every sphere of public life.

For in every sphere of society, from palace to marketplace, everything rises and falls on leadership. And leadership rises when God is with us, and when God’s people courageously make that presence known.

The writer is an Ordained Minister of The Methodist Church Ghana, writing on theology, ethics, and civic responsibility

The post Immanuel and the crisis of leadership appeared first on The Business & Financial Times.

Read Full Story